Fighting stance confusion

Why the Fighting Stance Fails Real Self-Defence

Walk into almost any striking martial art class boxing, karate, kickboxing, Muay Thai, taekwondo and you’ll see the same thing within minutes.

Feet staggered like they’re on train tracks. One foot forward, one back. Hands up, fists clenched, chin tucked. A classic fighting stance.
It’s efficient. It’s familiar.
And in a real self-defence situation, it’s often the wrong answer before anything even happens.

The First Problem: Self-Defence Is Not a Fight

The biggest misunderstanding in modern martial arts is this:
self-defence is not fighting.
A fight, whether people want to admit it or not, is an agreement. Two parties accept engagement. Ego, dominance, testing skill, something is mutually acknowledged.

Self-defence is the opposite.
It’s unwanted
It’s one-sided
It’s chaotic
And it’s usually over before you’ve even “set” your stance

Calling a street encounter a fight already romanticises it. Reality is dirtier than that. There are no rounds, no rules, no referees, and no reset button. The closest stone becomes a weapon. The closest stick becomes a weapon. The ground becomes a weapon. Numbers become a weapon.
Once you accept that, you have to question why we still teach people to look like they want to fight.

What the Fighting Stance Really Communicates

Let’s be honest about body language.
A fighting stance, with clenched fists and squared intent doesn’t just prepare you physically. It communicates something very clearly:
“I’m ready to go.”
To another person, to witnesses, to CCTV, to police later on, that posture says participation. It says escalation. It says willingness.
And that matters.

The Silent Camera Test

This is how I explain it to my students.
Imagine there is a camera in the distance.
It sees everything—but it hears nothing.
You might be saying:
“I don’t want trouble”
“Leave me alone”
“Back off”
But the camera doesn’t hear your words.
It only sees your actions.

What does it see?
Closed fists, shoulders forward, aggressive posture?
Or open hands, palms visible, hands raised in a universal sign of non-aggression?

That silent camera represents:
CCTV footage
Bystander testimony
Courtroom interpretation
In self-defence, how you look before contact matters as much as what you do after.

Hands Up Does Not Mean Fighting Stance

This is where many martial artists get confused.
They hear “hands up” and immediately think guard. But there is a crucial difference between:
Hands up to fight
Hands up to create a boundary
Open hands. Palms visible. Hands near head level. Elbows in. Body neutral, not bladed aggressively.

This posture does several things at once:
Protects your head
Signals “I don’t want this”
Allows fast reaction if violence happens
Shows restraint and intent to de-escalate
It is not passive.
It is responsible.
And responsibility is the foundation of real self-defence.

Why Martial Arts Keep Selling the Fighting Stance

So why do so many systems still push it?
Because most martial arts are built on:
Sport
Duelling culture
Mutual engagement
A fighting stance is clean.
It’s easy to drill.
It looks confident.
It photographs well.

More importantly it avoids dealing with messy reality:
Legal consequences
Pre-incident cues
Fear, confusion, hesitation
Moral accountability
Teaching people how to fight is easier than teaching people how to avoid violence without losing readiness.

The Legal and Moral Line

Here’s the uncomfortable truth:
The moment you adopt a clear fighting posture, you are stepping closer to being seen as a participant rather than a victim.
That doesn’t mean you can’t defend yourself. It means you must understand that self-defence begins before the first strike.

Open hands don’t make you weak. They make your intent unmistakable.
And if violence still happens? Then your response is clearly framed as necessity and not choice.

Self-Defence Is About Not Wanting to Be There

Real self-defence isn’t about winning. It’s about:
Getting home
Avoiding escalation
Surviving legally, physically, and psychologically
If you truly don’t want trouble, your body should show it.

Because in the real world, nobody cares how good your stance looked. They care about why it happened and whether it could have been avoided.

Final Thought

The fighting stance has its place in sport, training, and agreed combat.
But the street is not a ring. And self-defence is not a fight.
Sometimes the most powerful position you can take is not “ready to fight,”
but clearly unwilling to.

Written by Duanne Hardy

Instructor and owner of DKI Dojo, a karate school based in Port Elizabeth, Gqeberha (Kabega), focused on realistic self-defence, confidence, awareness, and discipline for children, teens, and adults.

Find DKI Karate Dojo online:

• Google Business Profile: https://share.google/4PoDkVOsM27Hs4xFV 

• Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/share/1Dyk7Re7sH/

• TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@duanneskaratejutsuinst?_r=1&_t=ZS-93AdG7NuzaM

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Shuhari- the understanding of transcendence

Shuhari — Protect, Break, Transcend There is a Japanese concept that has stayed with me for a long time because it explains learning far better than most Western models ever have. That concept is Shuhari (守破離) . Shuhari is often simplified as follow, break, transcend . While that isn’t wrong, it misses the depth of what the terms actually mean, and that depth matters. This idea doesn’t only apply to martial arts. It applies to trades, craftsmanship, teaching, and life itself. Shu (守) — To Protect Shu literally means to protect or preserve . This is the beginning stage of learning, where the student’s responsibility is not to innovate, but to safeguard the knowledge by learning it exactly as it was taught. In Shu: You follow the rules You copy without modification You respect structure and tradition You suppress ego in favour of discipline Shu is not blind obedience, it is humility. It recognises that before you can understand why something works, you must first learn w...
Read more

Everybody thinks they can fight.

Everybody Thinks They Can Fight Somewhere along the line, the idea of fighting became casual—almost expected. People believe toughness is enough. That bravery alone will carry them through. They confuse confidence with capability, aggression with skill, and ego with experience. Two minutes into a real fight, all of that fantasy collapses. The guard drops. The breathing goes. The feet stop moving. What’s left is panic dressed up as power. Big, looping punches swing wildly through the air, exactly like you’d expect in a bar fight—no structure, no defense, no awareness. The body tightens, the mind empties, and everything they thought they knew disappears under pressure. This is the reality for people who’ve done little to no training. Fighting is not instinct. Violence might be instinctive, but fighting—real fighting—is a learned skill. It requires conditioning, repetition, timing, composure, and an understanding of how the body behaves under stress. Without that, the body defaults to cha...
Read more

Reality of Self Defence for Kids

Kids, Martial Arts, and the Reality of Self-Defense Martial arts for kids can be a powerful and positive thing. Confidence, discipline, coordination, respect, routine — all of these are real benefits, and they matter. The problem does not lie in teaching children martial arts. The problem lies in how we define “self-defense” for a child and what we promise parents it can realistically do. There are many instructors out there, and most of them mean well. This is not about accusing anyone of lying or deliberately misleading people. There are rare cases where a child applies a technique correctly in a high-stress situation and escapes serious harm. When that happens, it feels almost miraculous. Some will say it proves the training worked — and in a sense, it did. But those cases are rare, and we need to be honest about that. A child is still a child. Children do not react the same way adults do under stress. Their nervous systems are still developing. Their strength, size, reach, and weig...
Read more